Showing posts with label NOAA debris model. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NOAA debris model. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Who said modeling was easy?

Modeling isn't as easy as it looks.

And yes, Tyra, it is.
No, not that kind of modeling. I'm talking about scientific modeling.  Scientific modeling is the use of information to create predictions about how something actually works.  This is being done with NOAA's tsunami debris models. And it isn't as simple as one might seem.

NOAA's new GNOME graphic has been released, but reveals very little about where marine debris is really washing up.  That leaves many asking- why can't we more accurately predict what is happening to tsunami debris?  NOAA has very extensive knowledge of ocean currents, wave energy, and circulation... why can't they figure it out?

Unfortunately, due to wave energy and a little principle we like to call entropy, tsunami debris is being washed and disseminated over a very wide swath of the Pacific ocean, and it might be argued that a predictive model at this point is very difficult and largely inaccurate.


Predict this- entropy in action. The third law of thermodynamics predicts that the universe, and matter, tends towards chaos.


The best information we have now is probably from field studies, such as the Gyre Expedition, that are taking visual accounts of marine debris as it makes its way across the Pacific.

NOAA's models show the highest concentration of debris remaining about 1,000 miles off the coast of North America, but the swath of debris extending all the way from Japan to the Aleutian Islands of Alaska, down to California in North America.

Tsunami debris is spreading across the Pacific in unpredictable ways. [NOAA]
There is always a limit to modeling, and as a system becomes more and more complicated, the less useful a model will be in determining what will happen in a real system.  This happens for two reasons. First, a model must be populated with parameters - the 'knowns' about a system- factors such as currents, wind speed, seasonal factors, etc. that tell us how the system will probably work.  In a system as complex as the Pacific ocean, it is very easy over-parameterize, or under-parameterize our models.

How do you create an accurate model?
A model is essentially a picture of how we predict a system to look like.  If we use too many factors to describe this system, we will only paint a picture of the system in one particular instance, that doesn't represent the full scope of possibilities.

Imagine that somebody asks you to paint a picture of a person.  They want it to look like a human, but nobody in particular- maybe for a road sign or stencil.
Somebody has just asked you to draw this
If you start drawing, and add more and more details, and finally end up with an exact replica of your Aunt Edna, well, you've done a very nice job of portraying your aunt, but this doesn't represent what the whole human population looks like.  You've just 'over-parameterized' your painting.
Now we all know what your aunt looks like, but this doesn't represent all people.

Conversely, we can under-parameterize a model as well.  What if you take that picture and draw a stick figure? It probably won't be useful to anyone. The same goes for modeling the real world.  If we take too few factors into account- say wind- that doesn't really show us what the outcome is going to look like either.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/94/Stick_Figure.svg/170px-Stick_Figure.svg.png
Underly-descriptive models aren't helpful either

Scientific modeling is a fine balance between being overly-specific and underly-descriptive.  For this reason, when situations are too overly-complicated, it can be nearly impossible create a model that really makes sense of the system.  Modeling debris was much easier when it was close to shore in the Western Pacific, but now there are just too many possibilities. Just like the smoke in the above animation.

That is why field studies, volunteer efforts and citizen reporting are becoming even more important.  As scientific problems such as debris become more and more complicated, and research funding becomes harder to find, beach cleanups, ocean surveys, and information from the public are going to be our primary sources of information for tsunami debris now.  For this reason, I strongly encourage my interested readers to volunteer for local cleanups, public events, and surveys.  You will not only be making a difference for the environment and wildlife, but also helping us understand the problem.





Thursday, December 13, 2012

Coastbuster and Citizen Science

 Greetings readers!

  The public is interested in the world around them, and today's climate and ecological issues are making news headlines daily.  Not surprisingly, new ways for people to contribute to this knowledge are popping up everywhere.

One field where this is especially true is ecology.  Several Apps have appeared for iPhone and smartphones that make it possible for any person to catalog ecological data about the world around them.  The first of these is a really cool application called 'Lampyr'. It was developed by an assistant professor at the University of Tennessee.  It is completely free, and runs as a website.  Today's social networking capabilities and smartphones have made citizen science increasingly possible.Once you visit lampyr.org on your smartphone or computer, the app uses your location information (be sure to enable location sharing!) to generate information on the specific biological species around where you are standing right at that moment.  Click on 'Find Closest Species' to instantly learn about the world around you.  Click on a species of interest for more detailed information. In addition (and most importantly), you can easily catalog species you see for others to learn about.

Now, what does this all have to do with this blog? Well, Lampyr is an excellent tool to learn about species around the ocean and intertidal zones near you.  But on top of this, other organizations have begun creating similar science applications that can expedite the gathering of data.  One of the newest of these is called Coastbuster by Ocean Networks Canada. It is particularly cool because, as I have stated before, volunteers and community members are going to be the front lines for tsunami debris, because there is currently little state or federal funding to deal with the inundation of debris that will wash onto shores in winter.

Coastbuster is currently only available for Android, and the iPhone version is still in development (I know, I know). Once you download Coastbuster, you will be able to open the app and are presented with a list of options.  You can either take a photo, or upload a photo that you have already taken.


By simply taking a photo of debris, adding a bit of additional information, you can contribute to a comprehensive catalog of marine debris, and make it possible for Ocean Network to identify hot spots of debris that could be in need of study or clean up. It will also be an extremely valuable tool for scientists who want to study how currents and winds influence the deposition of debris across our shores. Reports are anonymous, but are very valuable as we try to gather data regarding tsunami debris. This is a great way to be involved with your community while helping out researchers and volunteer organizations!  Keep an eye on my blog for news as to the iPhone application, and others that might be developed in the meantime.

--------------------------

So where is that debris now?  NOAA has updated their models, and it is slowly making its way inshore.  Models for early December show that the bulk of the debris is laying about 1,000 miles from the west coast of North America, but high windage and smaller items may begin showing up through January, when a majority of the flotsam is predicted to occur.

http://blogs.kqed.org/newsfix/files/2012/12/gnome_graphic.jpg
Model Projection: NOAA. Visit here for a larger image.


For those of you who still haven't seen the animated version of NOAA's debris model, visit this page for a brief background and the animation itself.